What is treatment resistant bipolar disorder?
There is no consensus among mental health clinicians/researchers on one definition of treatment resistance. In general, patients in an acute state (manic, depressed, mixed) who have symptoms that do not improve after at least 2 “evidence-based” medication trials are considered treatment-resistant in many research studies.
Treatment resistant bipolar disorder is of no fault to the patient, and may not be an indication of severe or “untreatable” disease – it may be that they simply are not being treated adequately or with the right medicine. This can be debilitating.
Combining multiple agents is the most commonly used clinical strategy for treatment resistant bipolar patients DESPITE a relative lack of data supporting this strategy (except for acute mania: lithium or valproate + a second generation antipsychotic is a treatment combination with strong evidence).
Unfortunately for patients and providers, there are not many strong, evidence-based treatment algorithms for such patients.
Treatment resistant bipolar disorder is particularly difficult to manage, as those with a bipolar disorder require management strategies that impact on both the manic/hypomanic and depressive aspects of the disease, and there is a large number of medication options (i.e., mood stabilizer, antidepressant, antipsychotic drugs, etc.).
It is difficult to standardize their use—particularly when many are prescribed in combination and effective dosages may vary widely from patient to patient.
An important study from 2017 attempted to discover what factors may be associated with treatment resistant bipolar disorder.
They discovered that treatment resistant patients were more likely to be:
- Receiving disability/support pension and less likely to be in full-time work (again, this is incredibly debilitating for the patient)
- Suffering from a higher number of lifetime stressors and medical conditions
- A later age at depression onset
- Reporting a higher incidence of a family history of depression
- Using benzodiazepines
- Suffering from more anxiety conditions and reporting a higher total number of anxiety disorders over their lifetime
- To view medication as a contributing factor to their depression
This may be consistent with the kindling theory of bipolar disorder whereby episodes become more serious and more frequent without effective treatment.
A good overview I have found is from Molecular Psychiatry on Treatment Resistance in Bipolar Disorder.
There are many factors that make the issue more complicated.
The three main sources of confusion are:
1. What stage of the illness the patient is at. It is now well-established that some medications work best for treating mania but different medications are better for treating bipolar depression, and still others are best suited for ongoing maintenance. So, is a patient being labeled as treatment resistant if they are receiving the wrong medications for their particular phase of the disease?
It is NOT unusual to try a few meds before finding your best bipolar treatment.
2. The difference between treatment resistance and treatment intolerance. What does this mean? Is it fair to categorize someone as treatment resistant if they abandon their medication not because of ineffectiveness but because of intolerable side effects?
3. What role does misdiagnosis pay? If I don’t respond to my bipolar medication, perhaps it is because I am not actually bipolar. Instead of asking, “Why doesn’t this work?”, should I be asking, “Am I bipolar?”
It is also important here to distinguish treatment resistant bipolar with treatment refractory bipolar. Generally, a patient is considered to be treatment refractory when, for example, their manic episode is not displaying a clinical response to 4-6 medication combinations.
This is assuming that they truly suffer from bipolar disorder; and often more complicated and even invasive treatment techniques can be necessary. But, let’s appreciate how frustrating this is for the patient.
They must endure several COMBINATIONS of different drugs, each of which may take 6-8 weeks to reach a “steady state” level in the central nervous system. For some, this can be tortuous, especially as each medication and each medication combination carries with it its own side effect profile.
Different treatments for mania, depression and maintenance
What looks like treatment resistant bipolar disorder can arise when we try to treat the wrong phase of the illness.
For example, for severe bipolar depression, lithium or Lamictal plus an antidepressant should be considered. Alternatives are quetiapine (Seroquel) or a olanzapine/fluoxetine combination (i.e Symbyax).
However, in acute mania when traditional mood stabilizers are inadequate, an atypical antipsychotic with strong anti-manic properties such as risperidone (Risperdal), aripiprazole (Abilify), or ziprasidone (Geodon).
For maintenance, where lithium or Depakote are ineffective, olanzapine (brand name Zyprexa) can be tried.
Alternatives in treatment resistant bipolar
What do psychiatrists usually try in the face of treatment resistant bipolar disorder? The main “fall-back” positions in severe bipolar mania are:
1. Combining traditional mood stabilizers such as lithium and valproate with the newer atypical anti-psychotics.
2. Continuing the antipsychotic and switching lithium to valproate or vice versa.
3. Switch to a different antipsychotic and add lithium or valproate (whichever was best tolerated in the previous trials).
4. Continue lithium or valproate and switch to yet another antipsychotic.
5. At this point, discontinuation of medication and initiation of ECT can be considered.
For treatment resistant bipolar depression, the STEP-BD trial is the only strong randomized controlled trial that attempted to distinguish which treatments are beneficial.
They used patients who were prescribed established mood stabilizers and at least 1 antidepressant and added lamotrigine, inositol, or risperidone. They found no significant between-group differences in depression response with any of the treatments.
However, the recovery rate with lamotrigine was 23.8%, whereas the recovery rates with inositol and risperidone were 17.4% and 4.6%, respectively.
It is also worth reading about emerging treatment alternatives, such as Mexiletine in treatment-resistant bipolar disorder.
(Mexiletine is used to treat certain types of abnormal heart rhythms. It works by blocking certain electrical signals in the heart to stabilize the heart rhythm and by blocking sodium channels.)
Other alternative forms of treatment in treatment resistant bipolar that have shown promising effects include:
- Triiodothyronine (T3) – The few available studies are flawed and small. However, many clues have been found suggesting that T3 could augment and accelerate treatment response with antidepressants, lithium, and perhaps with other treatment options.
- Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) – One study found that there was a significant change in depression scores from baseline to the end of week 4, 50% of patients responded and 40.9% achieved remission. No major side effects were observed aside from mild headache in some patients.
Does improving compliance lead to improved results?
This is a loaded question. There are many reasons why people are not medication compliant, even if medications have evidence to support them as effectively.
It is not unusual for people with poor medication compliance to think that “nothing works” and view themselves as having treatment resistant bipolar disorder. This is often a result of debilitating medication side effects.
These patients may not fit into the classic understanding of what treatment resistant bipolar is, but that does not take away from the fact that they are struggling and need treatment.
It is very important for both the patient and the provider to distinguish non-compliance due to intolerability of medication side effects with treatment resistance in bipolar disorder. This will help inform future treatment decisions that should be made as a team.
In Manic-Depressive Illness: Bipolar Disorders and Recurrent Depression, 2nd Edition, Doctors Goodwin and Jamison suggest the following to improve bipolar medication adherence:
1. Minimize dosage to the lowest possible effective dose.
2. Aggressively treat side effects.
3. Track compliance.
4. Examine concerns about long-term medication.
5. Educate patient and families about the role of medication and the dangers of “kindling”.
6. Encourage psychotherapy as well as medication.
Misdiagnosis – Am I bipolar?
As previously mentioned, seemingly “treatment resistant” bipolar disorder may in fact be misdiagnosed.
Researchers in Rhode Island discovered that many patients diagnosed as bipolar actually had borderline personality disorder. In fact, it appears to be becoming one of the most common misdiagnosis traps.
How to tell? Bipolar disorder is episodic, whereas borderline personality is a more pervasive and constant state.
The bottom line is that it is imperative to ensure that you have been properly diagnosed with bipolar before treatment resistance can be established
After beginning treatment, “Am I Bipolar?” may answer itself in that if mood stabilizers make you “better” (remove bipolar symptoms), then it is probably the underlying condition.
If you are unable to tolerate the side effects of the medication but felt some positive results, a different mood stabilizer should be utilized.
Certainly, we can be sure that there are patients out there who will not respond or be able to tolerate any of the currently available bipolar medications.
This notion begs the question, “Should researchers and drug manufacturers be working to develop more novel medications or alternative treatments?” I believe that they absolutely should.
What is this article talking about. It’s all about from a Doctors perspetive, not the patients. One’s not treatment resistant because they hate the meds. They all sucked for me. Made me worse. Every mood stabilizer made me sicker than my illness, These drugs are horrible for me and so many patients. It doesn’t matter what doctors say, it’s the patients that matter and how they feel. Hum. a study from UCLA. Again, from a doctors point of view. not the patients. How about if the doctors took the medications?. Lets see how they like all the awful side effects of feeling , sedated all day or wired that can’t sleep, crazy hunger, zombie like, fat, no sex drive, forgetful, dizzy all day long. This article says, Usually succesfull treatments! That’s a flat out lie. The facts are only about a third of patients respond to meds. People come off their meds or change them all the time. Why is that? It’s because they suck. . The article says this: However, it is not unusual for people with poor medication compliance to claim that “nothing works” and present themselves as having treatment resistant bipolar disorder. Duh, they can’t comply because the drugs are HORRIBLE, which means , it Doesn’t work. Who the hell can put up with the way they make one feel. What good is a drug if one can’t stay on it because they feel terrible. Have they come out with any new meds in the last decade besides Latuda? NO, nothing new. It’s the same drugs for the past 20 years. Same mood stabilizers. Nothing has progressed with newer more tolerable medications. Psychiatry is not a science. Dr’s have no idea which med will work and which ones don’t , everyone is different and they have no idea why. Dr’s all say TRY IT. Like its a piece of candy. Its messing with one’s brain. If one has an infection they take an antibiotic. With Bipolar you can go to 4 different doctors for an initial visit and each one will put you one something different from the other. I have seen over 20 different psychiatrists over the past 36 years. Each one has their favorite drug. Its trial and error. Expect when your suffering , who has the time for this you want to get better fast. They say stay on the meds for at least 6-8 weeks to see if it works. Your odds of a medication working are slim. Now you’ve wasted and suffered all that time to try another again for 6-8 weeks. It’s pathetic. We need meds that work faster and are more tolerable. I speak from 36 years of trying medications. I have a sibling who it took 12 years until she found Seroquel that worked. She was on every mood stibalizer and stayed on them for weeks on end suffering and waiting for them to work. It’s pathetic. This is the truth.
You are absolutely right. I was blown away by all the guessing. It is like physical illness 50 years ago. This is the best the psychiatric community has to offer? We need much more research and development to provide better treatment. If cancer was treated like this everyone would be outraged.
Nothing is helping me. After eight different medications I am sick of it. I felt better without taking medication. I. 100%✓ Sicilian this is probably a genetic disposition. I can’t sleep it’s 3 am right now I’m.habing bad bad headaches from geodon. I’m done with this. If I lived 42 years of my life without meds maybe I can live out the rest of my days at least being alert. Screw this
Alan is absolutely right!!! If i still had all the different bottles of all the crummy meds they told me to take i could open my own pharmacy! And he is so very right about the whole “take it for 6-8 weeks for full effect” bit. You suffer that whole time only to find out it’s not working and you have to start from square one. This is absolutely written from the physician’s point of view and no consideration has been given to the patient. Absolutely disgusted with this article as a whole.
ALAN! i hear you 100%. I have been on the medication roller coaster for years and have not found a mood stabilizer that hasn’t made me wish i had never even tried them.
I hear you. Medication is not a magic bullet cure because their isn’t one. I take Seroquel and an antidepressant and it keeps my head above water preventing me from committing suicide, thats it. Im bipolar, have severe, relentless anxiety and boderline personality disorder. I have chronic fits of anger, agitation and resentment several times a day. I think the BPD is more responsible for that than the BP issue. But yes, I agree with you that doctors have not taken the meds that we have amd therefore, dont know what the side effects are like. Many cannot take medication becaus the side effects are so ungodly intolerable. No argument there. Medication doesn’t work that well in general. I give the overall effectiveness of my medication a C- to a D. When people say medication say meds don’t work, I wonder if they have been misdiagnosed and have BPD instead…
This article hits on some really good points and also outlines some really good alternatives to medications. I wanted to add another potential option for anyone who has found that their medications are not working out very well for their depression. Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation also known as TMS Depression Therapy has become available since 2008 to help those with medication resistant depression. TMS is an outpatient treatment and works by sending magnetic pulses to the part of the brain where the chemicals are sluggish and causing depression. TMS activates these chemicals and helps alleviate the depressive symptoms. It is an option worth checking out and also much less invasive than ETC. Source: https://aneweratms.com/tms-really-work-depression/